Making the choice between an electric furnace vs a gas furnace can be difficult. Not only is there a lot of information to take in, but it's hard to know which one will be the best option for your home.
As your trusted Tacoma heating experts since 1992, Mercurio's Heating & Air Conditioning helps homeowners make informed decisions about their HVAC systems. Let's explore the key differences between gas and electric furnaces so you can choose the ideal option for your needs.
Factors To Consider When Choosing a Furnace
Installation Costs
The initial cost difference between electric and gas furnaces can be significant. Electric furnaces typically cost less to install because they don't require gas lines or venting systems. A new electric furnace installation usually ranges from $1,000 to $4,000. Natural gas furnaces are more expensive upfront and can cost between $3,000 and $6,000 to install.
Prices do vary based on your location, chosen system, and the complexity of the installation.
Monthly Utility Costs
When comparing electric vs gas furnace monthly costs, several factors come into play. Gas furnaces generally cost less to operate because natural gas prices tend to be lower than electricity rates. However, these savings can vary based on local utility rates and your home's insulation quality.
Maintenance Requirements & System Longevity
When it comes to gas and electric furnaces, both types of heating systems need regular maintenance. Gas furnaces require more attention due to their complex components and safety considerations. Regular maintenance helps prevent carbon monoxide leaks and allows you to locate hazards quickly.
However, if you rely on an electric furnace in an extremely cold climate, it could require more frequent repairs and tune-ups as it struggles to keep up with comfort demands.
Electric furnaces typically last 20-30 years with proper care, while gas furnaces usually serve 15-20 years. Annual furnace maintenance costs for electric systems tend to be lower since they have fewer moving parts and no combustion system.
Environmental Impact
The environmental impact of your furnace choice depends largely on your local energy sources. In the Pacific Northwest, much of our electricity comes from hydropower. This means electric furnaces can be a more environmentally friendly option.
Electric furnaces are also generally more thermally efficient than gas. This means they use a higher percentage of the heat they create to warm your space and waste less. However, electric furnaces often run for longer times. High-efficiency gas systems create heat more effectively and are therefore better in colder climates.
Gas furnaces produce carbon emissions, but newer high-efficiency models minimize this impact. Your personal environmental priorities may influence the decision you make.
Home Comfort & Heating Performance
Gas furnaces typically provide more intense heat and warm homes faster than electric systems. They maintain more consistent temperatures in very cold weather and heat the air to a higher temperature. Electric furnaces, however, typically offer more even heating throughout your home.
Safety & Peace of Mind
Modern furnaces have many safety features, but one type might be better suited to your home than another. Electric furnaces eliminate concerns about gas leaks or carbon monoxide poisoning, making them inherently safer in some ways. Gas furnaces require carbon monoxide detectors and regular inspections, but when properly maintained by professional technicians, they operate safely and reliably.
It's also important to conduct regular maintenance and inspections on electric heating systems, as unaddressed electrical issues can cause fires.
Making Your Decision
Choosing between a gas furnace vs electric furnace shouldn't be stressful. Consider these key points:
Choose an electric furnace if you:
- Want lower upfront costs
- Prefer simpler maintenance
- Have environmental concerns about fossil fuels
- Don't have existing gas lines
Consider a gas furnace if you:
- Want lower monthly operating costs
- Need faster heating performance
- Have existing gas service
- Live in an area with particularly cold winters
Expert Heating System Guidance
Every home is unique, and what works perfectly for your neighbor might not be the greatest choice for your family. That's why Mercurio's Heating & Air Conditioning is here to help! Our experienced technicians take time to assess your situation, considering factors like your home's size and your budget before making recommendations. We'll help you compare gas vs electric furnace options to find the perfect match for you.
Since 1992, our team at Mercurio's has helped Tacoma residents make informed decisions about their heating systems. Our comprehensive knowledge in HVAC, plumbing, and electrical service ensures your installation will be handled properly from start to finish.
We offer:
- Free Estimates
- Expert Installation by Certified Technicians
- Comprehensive Maintenance Plans
- Great Warranties
- Specials & Financing Options
Contact Us
Ready to explore your furnace options? Contact Mercurio's today for a free estimate. Our experienced team will assess your home's heating needs by:
- Understanding your energy concerns
- Discussing your budget
- Explaining available options
- Providing clear, upfront pricing
- Scheduling your install
If you're in need of professional furnace installation in Tacoma, WA, call (360) 499-2980 or contact us online. Let us help you make the right choice for your home's heating needs.
